[home page][map of the server][news of the server][forums][publications][Yabloko's Views]
Moscow Times, Oct. 25, 2002.

One Dead in Theater, 8 Walk Free

By Lyuba Pronina, Oksana Yablokova and Andrei Zolotov Jr

A sniper on Thursday targeting the front entrance to the theater where hundreds of people were taken hostage during "Nord Ost."

One woman was found dead and eight hostages including three children got out of the theater where about 50 Chechen separatists kept hundreds of people hostage for a second day Thursday in one of the most dramatic crises the country has ever seen.

Federal Security Service spokesman Sergei Ignatchenko, who met with reporters near the blocked-off zone around the theater, said Thursday afternoon that a 20-year-old woman was the only confirmed victim and she appeared to have been killed Wednesday night.

Television footage showed the body of the unidentified woman being carried out of the theater by Jordanian doctors, who were admitted after the Chechens said only non-Russian doctors would be allowed in. Negotiators had asked to be allowed to send in doctors.

Ignatchenko said the dead woman had been shot in the chest. He said her fingers were burned by gunpowder and broken.

One of the Jordanian doctors, Zake Ahmad, said there were about 800 hostages, including about 30 children, inside. "There are too many children there. The hostages are in need of medicine, food and medical assistance," Ahmad told Interfax. He returned to the theater after bringing out the body and spent several hours inside assisting the hostages.

"The condition of people is almost calm. Their attitude is almost normal," he said.

At about 5 p.m., the hostage-takers lobbed grenades at two women who managed to escape. Two explosions were heard outside the theater, a former house of culture near the Proletarskaya metro station in southeastern Moscow.

Ignatchenko identified the two women as Svetlana Kononova and Yelena Zinovyeva. He said a soldier was slightly wounded during the girls' escape.

The authorities established contact with the Chechens early Thursday morning, and their main demand remained vague but unchanged throughout the day -- for federal troops to be withdrawn from Chechnya. Smaller demands over the release of hostages changed almost every hour.

By late Thursday night it appeared that the crisis could drag on for days.

"The country's leadership and the special services have been thrust into a situation in which any outcome would be dramatic," former Interior Minister Anatoly Kulikov said on TVS television.

President Vladimir Putin, who reportedly spent the night at the Kremlin, made his first public comments about the crisis at 2 p.m. He canceled a scheduled trip abroad and described the hostage-taking as an unprecedented act of international terrorism.

He said the safety of the hostages was of utmost importance and suggested that the operation might have been planned by "one of the foreign terrorist centers."

"The main goal of our law enforcement agencies and special services in planning and conducting any operations should be the release of the hostages with maximum care taken to ensure their safety," Putin said during a televised meeting with Moscow Mayor Yury Luzhkov and police officials.

"For now, all forces must be focused on providing security to the adjacent territory, helping those who found themselves hostages and supporting their relatives," he said. "Caring for the people is the most important thing."

Russian television channels, some of which provided live coverage of the crisis throughout the day, also showed footage of Putin meeting with top security officials and Moslem leaders.

Foreign leaders condemned the hostage-taking and offered their support. Putin spoke over the telephone with U.S. President George Bush and Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, the Kremlin said.

The FBI and security services of Germany, Austria, Britain, Spain and France were cooperating with their Russian counterparts, Interfax reported. Foreign security officials were expected to arrive at the site Friday.

As the drama unfolded, curious onlookers gathered near the blocked-off site to discuss the crisis and possible ways to release the hostages. Armored personnel carriers and about a dozen empty buses were parked along nearby 1st Dubrovskaya Ulitsa.

At 1:15 p.m., State Duma Deputy Iosif Kobzon and two representatives of the International Red Cross waving a white flag entered the theater to talk with the Chechens. One of the hostages said that about half of the attackers were women.

Five hostages were released after the negotiations. The Red Cross representatives led an elderly British citizen out of the building at 1:30 p.m. Six minutes later, Kobzon emerged with the others, a woman with a 2-year-old daughter in her arms and two 7-year-old girls.

Later in the afternoon, lawmakers Irina Khakamada and Boris Nemtsov joined Kobzon in a second attempt to negotiate but failed to agree on the release of more hostages. "Judging by the chaotic way that they were changing the names [of people they wanted to negotiate with] and demands, it seems they are acting on their own, independently," Khakamada told reporters as she left the theater for the Kremlin.

Mark Franchetti, the Sunday Times' Moscow correspondent and the only reporter allowed in the theater, said he spoke with Chechen rebel Movsar Barayev for about 20 minutes.

Barayev, a nephew of slain Chechen field commander Arbi Barayev, leads a radical Chechen group.

Khakamada said the hostage-takers turned down her appeal to release the children. "They said they had already released all of the children, while 12- and 13-year-olds were not children," she said.

Yabloko leader Grigory Yavlinsky entered the theater for negotiations at about 11 p.m. He emerged at 12:50 a.m.

Officials and negotiators cautiously refrained from calling the hostage-takers "terrorists" or "Chechens." They referred to them instead as "gunmen" and "these people."

In a statement read by one of the released hostages, Maria Shkolnikova, the hostages appealed to Putin not to storm the theater and to comply with the Chechens' demands. Earlier in the day, relatives of the hostages made a similar plea on television.

Much of the drama Thursday unfolded over the air waves -- with cellphones intermittently being used by hostages and television and radio stations attempting to mediate.

"Our demands are very simple -- to stop the war and withdraw the troops. That's all. Nothing complicated," one of the hostage-takers, who identified himself as Hasmamat, said on Ekho Moskvy radio at 5:20 p.m.

When asked how such a huge task could be implemented, Hasmamat said: "Let Putin himself think about how to withdraw the troops that he sent there. There is enough time to pull out the troops, or at least half of them."

At one point Thursday, the hostage-takers demanded that representatives from Medecins Sans Frontieres arrive to mediate. The humanitarian organization's chief, Morten Rostrup, caught a flight for Moscow later in the day.

One demand reported several times Thursday was for a rally outside the theater demanding the withdrawal of the troops and Chechnya's independence.

"The government should make a statement that it is ready to begin negotiations [with Chechen leaders] and at least one military unit should be withdrawn," hostage Anna Adrianova said on Ekho Moskvy after consulting with one of the hostage-takers.

Former FSB spokesman Alexander Zdanovich said that talking to the outside world through hostages is a hostage-taker tactic. "We know that there is a certain hostage mentality that forms," Zdanovich told Interfax. "Some of them manage to keep a cool head, while others' nerves give out, and that is absolutely normal."

The hostages said they had water and chocolate, but all attempts to deliver food inside the theater failed.

"We repeatedly offered to deliver food and water, but they refused, saying, 'Let the hostages suffer as we do,'" said Russian Red Cross spokeswoman Marina Tarasenko.

Qatar-based television station al-Jazeera aired a pre-recorded tape of the hostage-takers saying they were ready to die for their cause. "I swear by God we are more keen on dying than you are keen on living," a man wearing black said on the recording, The AP reported.

"Even if we are killed, thousands of brothers and sisters will come after us, ready to sacrifice themselves," said a woman in a black robe that covered everything but her eyes.

The number of onlookers outside the theater grew in the evening. Some women, apparently hysterical, approached the police and offered to replace the hostages.

Three Chechen women came to the site in the afternoon to express their sympathy for the hostages. "We feel pain, shock, bitterness, and we are ashamed that Chechens did this," said one woman who only gave her name as Luiza. "We fear the consequences. Tomorrow, the police can knock on my door. People will consider every other Chechen a terrorist."

See also:
Act of Terror in Moscow

Reuters.Chechen Rebels Hold Hundreds in Theater, One Dead. October 24, 2002
The Moscow Times. October 24, 2002. Armed Chechens Seize Moscow Theater
the original at www.themoscowtimes.com

Moscow Times, October 25, 2002

[home page][map of the server][new items ][forum][publications][Yabloko's Views]

english@yabloko.ru